AI Song Royalties at Zero? Listeners Ask Whether Melon Should Stream It for Free

A new argument over an AI-vocal track moved from royalties to streaming fees and disclosure fairness. The songwriter's royalties and the recording producer's revenue are not the same thing.

Original media

Introduction

If listeners pay to stream a song while its songwriting royalties are zero, where does the money go? A Korean online discussion early on November 22 turned that question into jokes, suspicion and practical objections.

What happened

A Ruliweb post published at 1:17 a.m. on November 22 said simply that AI-song royalties were zero. Comments mentioned Melon and questioned its charges. Related reporting discusses the virtual AI vocalist MEOMURU's 'Have You Become the Adult You Dreamed Of?', whose audio is available on an Official Artist Channel.

Why it is trending

'Zero' is memorable; the financial system behind it is less simple. Listeners' subscriptions, songwriter royalties, producer revenue and platform fees became conflated, opening up a broader fairness debate.

People’s reactions

Three responses are visible in the actual public thread: a suggestion that an AI song should be free to listeners if no songwriting royalty is paid; sarcasm and suspicion about platform commissions; and a counterargument about people who disclose AI use versus those who do not. Comments also differed on whether commercially released AI music deserves protection. These observations are from one thread, not a representative survey.

Background

Music revenue includes separate rights for composers and lyricists, performers and record producers, alongside the streaming service. Whether human creative contributions can be demonstrated—and whether AI use was declared—are distinct questions from whether a song was successful.

Key facts

Reporting dated November 15 says this track is not registered with the Korea Music Copyright Association for songwriting, composition and arrangement royalties, but its recording-producer revenue is settled separately. A registration framework introduced on August 3 was withdrawn on August 25. It is therefore unverified to claim that no one earns anything from AI music or that Melon pockets every undistributed royalty. Exact platform-level settlement figures were not confirmed.

What to watch next

What happens next depends on revised registration rules, evidence of human authorship and the treatment of withheld royalties. Without authoritative settlement information, assigning the unallocated money to any single company would be speculation.

Sources & references

✳ AI-edited · Admin-approved · Editorial policy ↗

← Go back